Custom Throwback JerseysReviews 160

Was looking for a specific jersey of my favorite player as a teenager and came across this site.
Looked at the jersey I wanted and it looked perfect (at least thats what I thought).
I paid more than I wanted to ($227) but this was supposed to be a special purchase for myself. When I was updated that the jersey was coming that day, i was so excited. I got the notification that it arrived/went downstairs to pick it up/ opened the package and...
The $#*!ing thing didn't look remotely like the jersey they had on their site! Also they packed it so terrible, I've sent used shirts on Ebay better than that!
~ I tried calling them multiple time... no response. Look at the first pic of the one they have on their site (it has the pinstripes both on the inside and outside)
The one they sent me has WHITE on the inside & pinstripes on the outside giving it a cheap look. I've seen jerseys like this going for $58.99!
This company is $#*!ing dog$#*! for so many reasons and I've notified my credit card company to get a refund. $#*! THEM & dont get burned like I did.
Btw, read all their responses and they always have an excuse!
Pics include: 1- Jersey on their website
3- Jersey they sent me
1- calls i made to them (with no response from them
1 - proof of purchase

Reminded me exactly of the old Met Jerseys worn in the early 70s. The color, the stitching, the feel….just perfect. In fact, probably better than the ones they wore. Great job!

The shoulder striping is wrong. They have the actual jersey pictured on their website (see below) and they still got it wrong. It's supposed to fade on the back and on the front not be a big circle that goes all the way around the sleeve.

I have purchased over a dozen jerseys from CTJ. The first 10 or so were excellent, both in accuracy and quality. However, three of the last four jerseys I've purchased from them have inaccuracies that have spoiled those jerseys for me:

1.1976 Tampa Bay Buccaneers white jersey: The striping on the sleaves is wrong because whoever silkscreened the striping did it backwards--it should have been red lines screened over orange, but it was done the other way around, so the stripes are out of proportion to each other. The jersey I was sent did not match the pictured jersey on the website because of this and the seller would not offer an exchange for a corrected version.

2.80's Boston Celtics white jersey: The jersey had an extra-large "CELTICS" and extra thick sleeve striping that much more resembles the Celtics current white jerseys rather than the jerseys from the 80s. Again, the jersey I was sent did not match the jersey pictured on the website because of this and the seller would not offer an exchange for a corrected version.

3.80's Dallas Cowboys blue jersey: The serif number "3" on front ad back had an inaccurately large indentation compared with actual jerseys from this era. Once again, the jersey I was sent did not match the jersey pictured on the website because of this and I didn't even bother asking if the vendor would offer an exchange for a corrected version. Three strikes and you're out!

I have spent well over $3k on jerseys from CTJ. No more. They've seen the last penny and order from me.

This is the 2nd jersey i ordered to be custom made. 1st a throw back Ted Williams jersey and now a NY Giants Jason Sehorn jersey. Yes they take a while to deliver. But the jersey is great. I compared it to my Authentic LT jersey and couldn't find a difference. It was a little late but well worth the wait.
I will order again for sure!
Thank you

The jersey was exactly what I wanted, couldn't be happier.

It took awhile to arrive, but totally expected since was a custom order.

The material on my jersey was like a burlap sack with a really odd fit. Almost like different sections of the jersey are different sizes. Obviously not authentic. No response to return requests. Also, very pricey for a bootleg. I assume they conduct business in Canada so they don't get sued in the US.

I ordered a copy of a jersey I bought back in the 90s when I was a kid that, well, my now 25 years later self simply cannot wear comfortably. Photo reference is the Custom Throwback replica CCM (left) and my original 1990s Starter (right). Overall a job very well done that I can't find anywhere else. A solid win in my book.

I purchased what I believed would be an authentic reproduction of a 1986 NY Mets Keith Hernandez home jersey. The pinstripes are at least twice as wide as they ought to be and therefore the look is pretty unappealing, in addition to not having the "zig-zag" look that the real jersey's had.

Great store! With a great selection and quality! Thanks to the staff for your service and for your work!

Item still hasn't arrived. When I pointed to the fact that it was supposed to have been here by bow even with their incredibly long lead times I received rude snarky responses. Run for the hills and just make the short on your own as you could have by the time the person running the site fulfills your order.

This is how they treat their customers disrespect disgusting. They will never see a dime from me. They won't allow you to cancel. They crooks thieves! I wish I can give a -100 stars!

ABSOLUTELY THIEVES. THEY MAY SEND SOME CUSTOMERS THEIR JESEYS BUT NOT EVERYONE. BEEN TRYING TO EXCHANGE A JESEY FOR SIZE ISSUE SINCE FEB. 2022 (IT'S JULY NOW). IMPOSSIBLE TO REACH. THEY DO NOT RETURN EMAILS OR PHONE CALLS (UNLESS YOU SAY YOU WANT TO BUY A JESEY ON YOUR VOICEMAIL!)
**DOES ENYONE KNOW WHERE THIS BUSINESS IS LOCATED?***

I need to exchange my jerseys. They were supposed to be XL, but they are too snug. I needed their help.

HORRIBLE PEOPLE WHO RUN A HORRIBLE BUSINESS. CANCELED MY ORDER CAUSE I ASKED WHERE MY JERSEY WAS. HAVE REFUSED TO RETURN MONEY.
ABSOLUTE SCUM OF THE EARTH. MY LAWYER HAS FILED A COMPLAINT WITH THE BBB&CFPB.

Ordered the Sandy Koufax 1965 away jersey on 2/20/2022 and arrived today April 18,2022. The jersey is excellent and met my expectation. JH Los Angeles CA

Accidentally bought the same jersey multiple times because their website froze up on my iPhone. Quick refund.

I love this jersey! It's made with great quality. And a great price. Always wanted this jersey a true throwback!