business logo of Menards

MenardsReviews 351

1.2

On Sitejabber, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.

How would you rate Menards?
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star

Menards Reviews Summary

The customer feedback for Menards reveals a predominantly negative reputation, particularly regarding their customer service and product quality. Many customers express frustration over service delays, inadequate support during order issues, and a lack of accountability in handling returns and refunds. Complaints about damaged products and misleading rebate policies further exacerbate dissatisfaction. Although some customers appreciate the variety of products available, the overall sentiment indicates a significant decline in service quality and a perception of the company prioritizing profit over customer care. This suggests a critical need for improvements in customer service practices and product reliability to regain consumer trust.

This summary is generated by AI, based on text from customer reviews

service
143
value
131
shipping
84
returns
103
quality
116

We monitor reviews for authenticity

Iowa
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Craig O.
Unfollow Craig O.
Share Review
Report Review

Inferior products and no help when products fail. We bought dozens of sheets of pressure-treated plywood from Menards. Some of it began to delaminate within weeks, so we didn't use those portions. But now, within one year after installation, the installed pieces are delaminating left and right, especially the pieces that got wet. Old regular plywood is still holding up under the same conditions, but this new Menards plywood is bubbling out everywhere. Looks terrible. The whole project will have to be torn down, and all Menards plywood will have to be replaced. An extensive job, all over again, at a very high cost, AGAIN!

Date of experience: May 6, 2023
Missouri
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Mike R.
Unfollow Mike R.
Share Review
Report Review

Went to Menards in Independence, Mo. This morning (05/02/2030) to buy 2 pieces of siding. Their website said they had 27 pieces in stock. Went to the desk and ordered the 2 pieces that I needed and then proceeded to the checkout line. Waited in line for a little bit and got my business done.
I went to my truck and drove into the lumber yard. Found where the siding is and find out there is none. I then had to find an employee to help me. Well, he tried but no luck after about 15 minutes.
So I had to drive back around to the front of the store go inside and get a refund. What a waste of my time!
The employee that tried to help me in the yard said that the Belton, Mo. Store had 19 pieces. Great! (This is the closest store to the Independence, Mo. Store. 18 miles away.) On the way to the next store I decided I should call to make sure they had the siding in stock. Yes they said. 19 pieces. I'm on my way.
Arrived at the Belton, Mo. Store, went in side and ordered my 2 pieces. They told me again that they did have it. Went and stood in line again to pay for my order.
Drove around the back to the yard and found the siding. Guess what! There was one piece and it was in bad shape. I'm starting to get upset. Tracked down another employee to help me. For 20 minutes he tried only to find out that 1 piece is all they had. Now I'm really upset.
Drove around to the front of the building to go inside and get a refund. They didn't believe they were out and wouldn't refund my money until it was confirmed. Another 15 minutes. Really!
Finally get my refund and leave very unhappy. I can't believe that Menards doesn't know what they have in their yard. Is it really that difficult to know your inventory? Maybe Menards should pay better attention to their inventory so their customers aren't getting the run around and wasting valuable time. By the time I got to the job site it has been 2 1/2 hours of my time wasted. Told my customer what I went through and had to show them the refund receipts to back my story. My customer is now unhappy. Great! Thank you for that Menards. I have the old siding off the house and I'm trying to figure out what to do.to get my customers house closed up. Go to Home Depot 2 buy 2 pieces of plywood for a temporary fix. Not sure what to do now. The other home improvement stores don't carry the siding that I need. This has been a very bad experience. It has costed me almost $300 and a whole day wasted. Maybe even a customer.
I asked for a gift card or something at the Belton Mo. Store to help make up for this hassle only to be told they can't do that. Menards lost a customer today. I will not shop at Menards anymore.

Date of experience: May 2, 2023
Illinois
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Michelle M.
Unfollow Michelle M.
Share Review
Report Review

Menards is a rip off
April 30, 2023

I purchased my house in IL in August of 2022. I opened my Menards account shortly there after. My house in Virginia Beach had already sold. I ordered several things from Menards that were delivered to my house in IL. I purchased some column wraps for $2000 & somehow my Virginia Beach, VA address got uploaded into their system. I did not check the address for shipping since Virginia Beach does not have a Menards & all my previous items had been shipped to my IL address. The $2000 columns got shipped to Virginia Beach. My previous house was for sale again so it was an issue to have 6 large boxes blocking the walkway. I contacted Menards.com which you can only do through email & they told me it was my problem. I sent 2 subsequent emails to no avail. I paid less than $60 to have FEDEX pick it up and ship it to my house in IL. That $60 has ensured that I will NEVER shop Menards again for anything in my fixer upper in IL. You lost out on 10's of thousands of $ over $60. Did I mention I am a retired Navy veteran originally from WI? Yeah, my family knows, too. Way to go Menards, you just lost A LOT of business.

Date of experience: April 30, 2023
Illinois
2 reviews
3 helpful votes
Follow Sean T.
Unfollow Sean T.
Share Review
Report Review

I went to Menards design center to have them help me design a deck. The person I worked with was awesome, but the program Menards uses to tell you what products I needed to build my deck were WILDLY off...12 post holes to be dug, 212 bags of concrete they sold me, then they are charging me to return it, and all the other extra stuff they told me I would need, and clearly didn't! Don't go here and get ripped off! $12,500 in materials I bought and paid for, and probably over $2,000 in stuff they told me I'd need and I don't. The Manager I spoke with, Tom A, was rude and condescending when I told him about my frustration, and refused to help me the the expense of the return. Totally took advantage of me, because if it was an honest mistake that they made, they wouldn't charge me to return the stuff! I trusted them, please don't make the same mistake I did...go somewhere else!

Date of experience: April 30, 2023
Missouri
8 reviews
8 helpful votes
Follow trace w.
Unfollow trace w.
Share Review
Report Review

0 star if that was an option. All i can say is I will never never buy from Menards again, I had a 11.00 rebate, I know not much, but the post office lost it, never got it, i requested to have it cancelled and resent. Once I got it, The inconsiderate crooks took 6.00 bucks of the check, Never have I seen something so ridiculous, Home Deport or Lowes would never have done such a selfish thing. Wont recommend Menards to anyone!

Date of experience: April 30, 2023
Minnesota
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Cynthia K.
Unfollow Cynthia K.
Share Review
Report Review

MARK IS GREAT!
April 24, 2023

Yesterday, I went to the Oakdale Menards to look at roofing shingles and coordinating paint for my home. My son was with me. We shopped and picked out the ideal shingles and paint colors. Unfortunately, a sample of the shingles I wanted didn't have a sample board on the floor. There was a shingke sample way up on the wall. Lucky for me, Mark came along and asked if we needed help. I was reluctant to ask, but thought, why not. I explained I wanted to see my paint samples next to the shingles on the wall. Mark immediately said he could help me out. It was amazing. Love the combination of paint with the shingles, firmed up my decision to get the shingles and paint for my home, that got last year's hail storm damage. Many, many thanks to Mark for being there for me when I needed help. Great service, you are the best.

Date of experience: April 22, 2023
Illinois
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Melissa S.
Unfollow Melissa S.
Share Review
Report Review

Plant rescue
April 22, 2023

Saturday as I felt the need to purchase a house plant as my first plant. The plant was priced for 44.65, I said well it's the only plant I can probably afford. And the plant had dried leaves and soil it was the only one I wanted to purchase. When I go to the counter I asked for a discount as it was half way dead and the lady said no. I was like not even 10percent she said no. I am disappointed because plants are a need inside everyone's home and Mr, Menards should be able to understand that a little discount could have saved the dried plant that I wanted to purchase. I was not happy with this experience and hope no one has to go through what I experience with the plant that is not being watered or cared for.

Date of experience: April 22, 2023
Ohio
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Rick N.
Unfollow Rick N.
Share Review
Report Review

Scammy
April 15, 2023

They advertise price after rebates, which you must jump through hoops and pay postage to send in and likely never get. I've mailed in 6-7 rebate forms and never received one. These people have no scruples, and you only encourage their greedy, unscrupulous ways by shopping there.

Date of experience: April 15, 2023
Wisconsin
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow John S.
Unfollow John S.
Share Review
Report Review

House plans
March 29, 2023

I have purchased house plans and been told that After purchasing they will send plans to their estimators company for material list which was a lie
Now they telling me to pay $299.00 for it
What a scam! I was stupid to deal with Menards. I could get plans elsewhere for the price of Menards with materials list
Don't deal with Menards
Home Depot is got 11 % also and you don't have to purchase for your rebate

Date of experience: March 29, 2023
Massachusetts
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow N o n.
Unfollow N o n.
Share Review
Report Review

Terrible product, runaround on return
March 29, 2023

Ended up cutting my losses and saving my sanity and throwing the product in the trash. Menards got their money, so they do not care. Dont give them any more.

Date of experience: March 29, 2023
Ohio
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Irma M.
Unfollow Irma M.
Share Review
Report Review

Management accuse me of placing a box into a slot so that I can get a cheaper price I said check cameras I can't help it if someone put a box in the wrong place and then had the nerve to say God help help with what with her calling me a thief? Yes, God help us, and then, when I asked to speak to the store manager, who, by the way, was younger than her, who by the way, she couldn't speak very good English, which made it very difficult for me to understand what she's asking me for this kit number I don't work here why are you asking me for a skid number horrible just horrible. I can see why they got one ratings. I don't understand is how they're still in business customers are always right. I am totally check the cameras I'm not a thief. I hope that still goes under and God help it go under.

Date of experience: March 25, 2023
Illinois
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Just JIm J.
Unfollow Just JIm J.
Share Review
Report Review

11%? No...
March 24, 2023

I used to like shopping at Menards.

If you look at the ad, you will notice that the prices are being raised to accommodate for the "11%" discount. After discounts are applied, items are $2.99 or $19.99. These are the prices they wanted in the first place. A tub I purchased 4 months ago for $260 suddenly increased to $288.60. After the "rebate", it dropped back down to $260. They are also betting on the fact that you will not send in the rebate

Date of experience: March 24, 2023
Washington
2 reviews
3 helpful votes
Follow Leroy F.
Unfollow Leroy F.
Share Review
Report Review

I needed to return and refund two items that I bought online from Menards. When the items arrived, it was immediately apparent that one of the items was defective, so I used Menards website to request an RMA and return shipping label. Jess V. in Menards Online Customer Service researched the purchase, and quickly facilitated my receipt of a FedEx Return Label. During the brief interim period between my request and my receipt of the return label, I discovered that the second item I had received was also defective. Both of the fragile items, Black Flag "bug zappers" had apparently been severely jarred during shipping. The tube in one of them was completely dark, and the tube in the other one flickered and buzzed. I replied to Jess V.'s email, requesting an amendment to the RMA, which would enable me to return both items with the label I had already received. Jess V. quickly accommodated my request to change the RMA, from 1 item to 2 items, so I could return both items in the original Menards shipping box, using the return label I had already received. I am very pleased with the excellent customer service provided by Jess V., and I will definitely buy from Menards whenever possible.

Date of experience: March 17, 2023
Kansas
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Ann T.
Unfollow Ann T.
Share Review
Report Review

Bad customer service
March 17, 2023

We went to Manhattan ks menards to purchase washer and Dryer, we found what we like and the price was about $1500.00, they would not wave delivery fee that is a couple hundred dollars, and they want to charge us $40 each to move our old Washer and Dryer. The Lady that was helping us called the manager if he is able to get the delivery fee waved, he refused. Who in the right mind would loose a $1500 dollar business for a couple hundred dollars? Their customer service is horrible. I refused to spend my money there and went to Home depot, we found a better Washer and Dryer and free delivery! Ofcourse great customer service! I will never shop at Menards again!

Date of experience: March 17, 2023
Ohio
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow m T.
Unfollow m T.
Share Review
Report Review

My story is that we were at the store to purchase a product and that the items we wanted were not carried at that store. The Menard's associates advised us to de a special order. We attempted to return the item and we advised of the 25% 'RESTOCKING FEE'. Here is the real issue: The item was available for purchase from menards.com and if purchased there it could be returned. I politely pointed this out to their "customer service' department and was told bluntly that their is no refund on the restocking fee. Only callous and poor business practices would say my future business was not worth $45.00. I'll never shop there again.

Date of experience: March 13, 2023
Illinois
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow PAUL H.
Unfollow PAUL H.
Share Review
Report Review

Screwed by delivery
March 3, 2023

I only asked for HALF the delivery fee back! No- $20 and too bad...
I bought 2 pieces of furniture. I made sure they knew exactly where it needed to go before purchasing. $170 for delivery. They brought the first "lighter" item in, the second "heavier " piece of furniture never even came off the truck.
The delivery guys said no way. $20 dollar refund? They agreed to a service, complete half of the service, but will only refund $20. I Would have not purchased if they didn't tell me "we will deliver it ".
Now I have to pay another delivery for the furniture with a company that will stand by their agreement. You are just a name on a mailing list to them.
This was a personal purchase but be sure, I could have gotten whatever I wanted if I went to my Contractor Rep.
I already cut my Contractor Card in half.
The everyday customer is what keeps the company going.

Date of experience: March 3, 2023
Wisconsin
1 review
4 helpful votes
Follow Fuck F.
Unfollow Fuck F.
Share Review
Report Review

Fake 11% Rebate
March 1, 2023

While purchasing a new wash machine on11/26/2022 I made sure and even asked sales person about the usual 11% rebate on this item and was even instructed where to grab on the way out. Come to find out after waiting 3 months that the rebate offer had expired on 11/23/2022. This I find disgusting that sales staff was not up to date on merchandise and I was under the impression it was 11% as usual. Have done quite a bit of shopping there in the past but NOT ANYMORE! MENARDS SUCKS!

Date of experience: March 1, 2023
Ohio
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Dale V.
Unfollow Dale V.
Share Review
Report Review

Rented a truck 300.00 deposit told me they put it back on my card when I returned the vehicle, which was a lie it takes 7-10 days, I would never rent again nore would i recommend them I'll use lows next time

Date of experience: March 1, 2023
Iowa
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Rita W.
Unfollow Rita W.
Share Review
Report Review

Countertops
February 21, 2023

Went to menards on Saturday ordered countertops for my home. Got to the register and they double charged me for one item good thing I had not paid for it. I told the lady at the register it was wrong so she called a girl over to cancel the order. One gentleman was nice enough to get it straightened out with. Left the store was going to go to dinner and the people in delivery called and said I never paid for my delivery. I explained to him that I did and paid cash the gentlemen says according to our records u didn't so I said I would go home get the receipt and bring it to menards.10 minutes had gone by and some lady called and said she found the receipt first of all I hate being called a liar. So we went back to menards had a question on my receipt and the same girl that canceled out my order at the register was the girl they called to help me. Her attitude sucked she should not be working in customer service when I questioned the bill she says and I quote what do you want me to do that's not my dept.Ok then get someone that could help me she was so rude and I am done shopping there. I spent over 900.00 dollars in countertops and that's how they treat people. This was at the store in waterloo iowa. I worked customer service for 9 yrs and I wouldn't treat people like that.

Date of experience: February 21, 2023
Ohio
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Danny T.
Unfollow Danny T.
Share Review
Report Review

$#*!TIEST STORE ON EARTH
February 10, 2023

Drove 45 minutes from jobsite. Bought 2 pine solid doors 28".
Get to jobsite to install them,.they are 24"! Took them back next morning, told manage the stickers on them say 27 13/16 (28") bet actual size is 24". Someone labeled them WRONG.
3 hours + of my time and gas, and he said he can exchange them but NO REBATE OR DISCOUNT fo THEIR SCREWUP?!?!?!?!?!? Asked for number to regional office, called while there and cannot speak to ANYONE! FILE COMPLAINT BY MAIL OR FAX?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
AMERICA SHOULD STOP BUYING THERE AND BOYCOT THEM AND WATCH THEM GO BANKRUPT AND SHUT DOWN. WORST STORE EVER.
I am a small business owner, I do Remodeling. The store was DALLAS PIKE, TEIDELPHIA WVA...
Will NEVER SHOP THERE AGAIN!

Date of experience: February 10, 2023