New York Shirt Company
website thubmnail of New York Shirt Company

New York Shirt CompanyReviews 125

2.2

On Sitejabber, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.

How would you rate New York Shirt Company?
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star

New York Shirt Company Reviews Summary

New York Shirt Company has a rating of 2.2 stars from 125 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers dissatisfied with New York Shirt Company most frequently mention customer service and tracking number. New York Shirt Company ranks 95th among T Shirts sites.

service
36
value
27
shipping
30
returns
21
quality
26
This company does not typically respond to reviews

We monitor reviews for authenticity

New York
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Peter V.
Unfollow Peter V.
Share Review
Report Review

I ordered a shirt paid for express shipping i needed it for an event that was Saturday the 7th and I am still waiting for the shirt. I asked for a refund they played games with it I ask for the 40 dollars I paid for express shipping nothing. Don't buy from this company

Date of experience: May 30, 2025
Arizona
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Jess B.
Unfollow Jess B.
Share Review
Report Review

They lie completely
September 25, 2022

Please do not buy anything from them you think that is a discount you think that is going to be service better than Etsy but these individuals lie about everything they are very dishonest and very disrespectful and they're holding on to pennies while offering poor customer service you think that they'll just provide positive customer service to get repeat customers but their services be on disrespect and just a bunch of Lies they don't even communicate with you on a timely manner or follow a chain of emails that they keep on sending you is a different person replying every single time go to Walmart go to Target go anywhere you can but please do not shop at this company they need to hopefully go out of business or do something major it's nothing but dishonesty

Date of experience: September 25, 2022
California
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Jamie F.
Unfollow Jamie F.
Share Review
Report Review

Awesome shirts
May 19, 2022

I absolutely love my shirts they fit great I love what they say I will be purchasing more The T shirts fit absolutely perfect...

Date of experience: May 19, 2022
New York
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Robin R.
Unfollow Robin R.
Share Review
Report Review

Beautiful shirts
April 29, 2022

I think the quality of these shirts is great. The colors are vibrant and they material is soft. The sayings are very strong.

Date of experience: April 29, 2022
Pennsylvania
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Virginia G.
Unfollow Virginia G.
Share Review
Report Review

T shirts
January 5, 2022

Shirts were delivered on time and are of good quality got 7 or 8 of them I kept 3large the rest were Christmas gifts. My shirts are to tight after sometime back and forth they agreed to send me an x-large as I wore one and replaced one so make sure you order the right size

Date of experience: January 5, 2022
India
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Cheryl H.
Unfollow Cheryl H.
Share Review
Report Review

Happy with your shirts
October 9, 2021

Best shopping platform. Come all and enjoy your experience with these great shirts. I love them all...

Date of experience: October 7, 2021
Oregon
3 reviews
1 helpful vote
Follow Kim M.
Unfollow Kim M.
Share Review
Report Review

I ordered 8 tshirts from New York Shirt Company in March 2021. I finally got my order in late June after contacting them twice. One shirt was missing, 1 shirt was correct and 6 shirts were wrong sizes and colors. I contacted them and have been asked to send pictures of them, which I have done 4 times now as they keep asking for them again. Sam, the founder, emails and says they will make it right but they have done nothing except make promises and send me emails to order more shirts. Save yourself the hassle and wasted money and don't order from them!

Date of experience: October 4, 2021
Texas
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Michael H.
Unfollow Michael H.
Share Review
Report Review

BEST ON-LINE COMPANY!
September 16, 2021

I LOVE THE NEW YORK SHIRT COMPANY! Everything I've ordered arrives & looks better than anticipated. The quality is fabulous. Overall value and satisfaction is perfect

Date of experience: September 16, 2021
Missouri
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Lola D.
Unfollow Lola D.
Share Review
Report Review

Why oh why didn't I read the reviews first. I've been waiting since July 16th‍ The 3 shirts that I wanted for special events Labor Day Weekend won't happen. Email after email, lame excuse after lame excuse. Trying to get a refund is like pulling teeth. Good luck

Date of experience: September 3, 2021
California
3 reviews
0 helpful votes
Follow Lori S.
Unfollow Lori S.
Share Review
Report Review

If you are submitting a positive review for this company, you are either being paid to do so, you are an employee of this company that their job was threatened if you didn't do so, you are the incredibly embarrassed family of these company owners, or you are certifiably insane.

Date of experience: August 29, 2021
Vermont
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow LISA H.
Unfollow LISA H.
Share Review
Report Review

BUNCH OF IDIOTS
August 26, 2021

I PLACED AN ORDER IN APRIL AND IT FINALLY SHIPPED IN JULY AND I MOVED IN MAY. I ADVISED THEM THAT I MOVED, GAVE THEM MY NEW ADDRESS AND THEY SAID THEY WOULD SHIP MY ITEMS TO MY NEW ADDRESS... I JUST GOT A NOTIFICATION MY ORDER SHIPPED AND GUESS WHAT THEY SENT IT TO THE SAME ADDRESS I JUST TOLD THEM I MOVED FROM. I EMAILED THEM AND THEY SENT BACK MY TRACKING NUMBER. OBVIOUSLY THEY CANNOT READ EITHER. NEVER DO BUSINESS WITH THIS POOR EXCUSE OF A COMPANY!

Date of experience: August 26, 2021
Mississippi
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Janice A.
Unfollow Janice A.
Share Review
Report Review

Unhappy customer
August 25, 2021

It is ashame that a $6.99 shirt cost 17.99 when you go to check out. I will not be ordering from them

Date of experience: August 25, 2021
Maryland
2 reviews
0 helpful votes
Follow S E.
Unfollow S E.
Share Review
Report Review

NYtshirt Company delays
August 23, 2021

Prices are great. I ordered my tees May 15 for 4th of July cookout. They were delivered July 31st. I actually forgot about them. Many reviews indicate they have not received order. It takes a while. Plan and be prepared to wait around 3 months. They should make customers aware of delays.

Date of experience: August 22, 2021
Illinois
2 reviews
1 helpful vote
Follow Darlene A.
Unfollow Darlene A.
Share Review
Report Review

Top notch company
August 21, 2021

I have ordered 5 times since the end of June. I have received my orders in about 2 weeks. They email me if there's a problem with my order. I love there product the colors are vibrant and some of the colors are different types like red I have a few red shirts but the color is not the same I like that. I love the sayings and the prices. I trust this company thank you

Date of experience: August 21, 2021
Missouri
2 reviews
0 helpful votes
Follow Vianna A.
Unfollow Vianna A.
Share Review
Report Review

Company
August 20, 2021

This company is so great. I really love to scroll through the T-Shirts and when I find one i Most likely will buy it. This is a great company if your looking for Crazy, humorous, or something that will make you laugh. I am so glad I found this company, all my T-Shirts come from them. People should really try this site out, you won't be disappointed.

Date of experience: August 19, 2021
Texas
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Tammy F.
Unfollow Tammy F.
Share Review
Report Review

I finally got my shirts... 2mo later
August 14, 2021

I ordered 2 shirts in June 2021... I didn't get them until yesterday (Aug 2021)... seriously... Multiple times... I called. No response or apologized... I gmailed and days later they would respond just to say I'm sorry we're short-handed, we're working on it, or sorry for the delay it's because of covid. Wth... See attached pics. They are supposed to be same size... yeahhh the label says they are but they are clearly not, and one shirt was already raveling out on the shoulder when I took it out of the bag they shipped it in. I had planned on buying more shirts but because they took so long I will not be purchasing anything else and neither will anyone else in my family.

Date of experience: August 14, 2021
Tennessee
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Sue S.
Unfollow Sue S.
Share Review
Report Review

T-Shirts
August 11, 2021

I have ordered several shirts from this company. They have always arrived in a timely manner. They are very reasonably priced too! All of my shirts that I have ordered are very comfy and fit true to size.

Date of experience: August 10, 2021
California
2 reviews
0 helpful votes
Follow Damaris M.
Unfollow Damaris M.
Share Review
Report Review

Purchase
August 7, 2021

Placed order May 16th and still have not received my order. I keep asking for them to cancel and refund my order and they refuse. Taking legal action.

Date of experience: August 7, 2021
Texas
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Harriett E.
Unfollow Harriett E.
Share Review
Report Review

I am a recent newcomer... I have ordered multiple shirts and have found them to be very nice quality. Thank you for the great shirts!

Date of experience: July 22, 2021
Michigan
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Debbie E.
Unfollow Debbie E.
Share Review
Report Review

Satisfied customer.
July 20, 2021

Have placed several orders. Satisfied with every order. Do not be discouraged. Sometime it may take a little longer than others, but they always come thru. Worth The Wait

Date of experience: July 20, 2021