business logo of Italo Jewelry

Italo JewelryReviews 544

2.8

On Sitejabber, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.

How would you rate Italo Jewelry?
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star

Italo Jewelry Reviews Summary

Italo Jewelry has a rating of 2.8 stars from 544 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers dissatisfied with Italo Jewelry most frequently mention customer service, tracking number and return policy. Italo Jewelry ranks 12th among Engagement Rings sites.

service
110
value
104
shipping
110
returns
82
quality
99
This company does not typically respond to reviews

We monitor reviews for authenticity

Florida
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Marta L.
Unfollow Marta L.
Share Review
Report Review

Lost in transit
June 24, 2025

I have been dealing with italo for over a month on a purchase i made that if I hadn't been checking, I would have never known that my purchase was list in transit. After approximately 15 or more emails, of which maybe 5 were answered via a scripted email, I was told that they would be shipping me what I like to call a replacement. For free, which is a joke because my original purchase was over the amount that qualifies for free shipping. They have yet to respond to my inquiries regarding when this second shipment will be sent. Now I received a fedex bill for 10.62 from Homeland security to a place called triple eagle. All I am asking for is a resolution. I work hard for my money and wanted to treat myself, since in all honesty, their jewelry is very pretty and somewhat affordable.

Date of experience: June 2, 2025
Minnesota
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Sheri S.
Unfollow Sheri S.
Share Review
Report Review

Buyer Beware!
April 15, 2025

After purchasing a beautiful ring from Italo Jewelry, it arrived but was too snug. This despite my using a professional jeweler's sizing tool before selecting the size. I reached out to the Company by email, told them how much I liked the ring, but needed to have it sent in a size 8, versus the 7.5 I ordered. I sent 3 emails to the Company before they responded. And when they responded, they ignored my request for the specific address where I could return the 'too-snug' ring. They did advise me I could keep the ring that didn't fit, if I would pay another $60 for the replacement ring, and another $20 in shipping charges. NO. The worst? I actually looked at the reviews on their website before I placed my order. Their site declares 99% of reviews are 4 and 5 stars. That seemed impressive. Until I tried to post my own review (spent far too much trying) and have discovered there is NO WAY to post a review. I feel certain this is by deliberate design on the part of Italo. And I'm also feeling it is quite possible the reviews which ARE on their website are either highly manipulated or non-authentic. Shame on you Italo!

Date of experience: April 15, 2025
Indiana
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Gary T.
Unfollow Gary T.
Share Review
Report Review

C/S agents don't call back or they hang up on you because they don't speak English very well. Don't understand your issue

Date of experience: January 7, 2025
New Jersey
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Claudia C.
Unfollow Claudia C.
Share Review
Report Review

BEWARE!
January 12, 2025

Bought a sapphire necklace and ring. Hated them immediately upon receipt. Tried to return and got other offers instead. Finally received return instructions. Returned both. No refund. They have had items intact in boxes in which they came and no refund yet. BEWARE!

Date of experience: January 12, 2025
New York
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Marie M.
Unfollow Marie M.
Share Review
Report Review

Ripped off
December 20, 2024

I placed an order on November 11th and after ordering it I saw on the tracking that it wasn't going to be delivered because they didn't pay correct postage for it. Then they tell me I will get a full refund that should have been $109.95 and they only are refunding me $76.96. This is unreal. They are taking out shipping for an item they didn't even pay correct shipping for. I am trying to get back in touch and no one is answering. STAY FAR AWAY FROM THIS PLACE!

Date of experience: December 5, 2024
Florida
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Camila L.
Unfollow Camila L.
Share Review
Report Review

Be aware this company ships from China and they never give you a date when you should receive your order. I placed an order on 11/08/2024 and today is 12/15/2024 and my order is still in transit in Chicago and I live in Florida. I hope I still receive my order. I will never order again because it takes too much time to receive. I will come back to update my review when I finally receive my order and if I receive it.

Date of experience: December 15, 2024
California
1 review
4 helpful votes
Follow Deborah R.
Unfollow Deborah R.
Share Review
Report Review

Crooked company
October 12, 2024

I ordered two rings and needed to return one because of the fit. I was only reimbursed a portion of my cost because I had a discount on the original purchase and they would not honor that. Instead, they subtracted a smaller discount from the ring I kept. Never ever again! And the ring is only silver plated, not real silver.

Date of experience: October 12, 2024
California
2 reviews
3 helpful votes
Follow Glayds U.
Unfollow Glayds U.
Share Review
Report Review

Elegant Fancy ring Beyond expectations! Very happy to have bought it. Find a perfect ring in exact price. Quality is also awesome. Product gets my recommendation for sure."

Date of experience: April 26, 2024
Ohio
2 reviews
2 helpful votes
Follow Tammie B.
Unfollow Tammie B.
Share Review
Report Review

I had trouble with every order with this operation. Its basically a bate and switch deal. Customer service is a joke they try to put you thru all kinds of hoops to get your money back. And forget about trying to return a order they will try to offer you a bunch oh B.S.

Date of experience: April 18, 2024
Texas
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Alma R.
Unfollow Alma R.
Share Review
Report Review

SCAMMERS!
March 21, 2024

I purchased 2 rings from them last 12/23. I had them mailed to where I would be for the holidays, took 2 months 2 get when I got them my niece showed them to me on FaceTime time and they were so cheaply made. They then asked I send it to a different address threatening needed to do so within 7 days of receiving it, since I live in another city my niece sent it back to the address where shipped from in the beginning, (they requested an address in New Jersey that was not a business) now they say never received the merchandise and I do not have a refund, I will constantly be writing bad reviews on these SCAMMERS!

Date of experience: March 21, 2024
Washington
2 reviews
2 helpful votes
Follow Teresa M.
Unfollow Teresa M.
Share Review
Report Review

So happy you have it
February 24, 2024

This is a beautiful ring and it fits great just got it in the mail. I love it. Beautiful ring, just as described, I would definitely recommend

Date of experience: February 22, 2024
Pennsylvania
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Brittany A.
Unfollow Brittany A.
Share Review
Report Review

Customer Service!
February 20, 2024

I hardly ever write reviews however I felt compelled to do so with Italo Jewelry. I am beyond pleased with the fast shipping, delivery and quality of the items- for not being real diamonds, they sure do mimic my wedding set perfectly. In addition, the customer service is out of this world. I ordered the wrong size and sent and email and the customer service team was quick with all responses and found a way to make the situation better. Not only was the return policy easy, I was able to exchange my items for the correct size(S) AND they sent me a free gift of beautiful earrings for exchanging versus returning my items. I am currently buying more items from Italo and have recommended them to so many people in my personal life. I promise, the money spent on this jewelry is well worth EVERY PENNY spent!

Date of experience: February 19, 2024
Indiana
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Patrick R.
Unfollow Patrick R.
Share Review
Report Review

THIS COMPANY IS A SCAM - AVOID!
January 7, 2024
Updated review

Italo Jewelry is a scam company. From broken jewelry, to painted beads being described as pearls, to horrible, horrible customer service…AVOID THIS COMPANY! A picture is worth a thousand words…SEE BELOW! That's Italo's version of a pearl band ring after 8 months, rarely worn! Spread the word about this company…I surely will continue on every forum possible!

Date of experience: January 7, 2024

NEVER ORDER FROM THIS COMPANY!
December 26, 2023
Previous review

NEVER ORDER FROM THIS COMPANY! This is the condition of their pearls, or should I say - painted beads after a year! DO NOT BE DUPED BY THIS COMPANY! GARBAGE CUSTOMER SERVICE EQUALS THE GARBAGE JEWELRY QUALITY!

Date of experience: December 26, 2023
New Jersey
1 review
5 helpful votes
Follow Patricia F.
Unfollow Patricia F.
Share Review
Report Review

Ordered 3 beautiful rings. At first it was accidently delivered to the wrong address but upon notifying Italo customer service they sent me a replacement. When the order arrived they were even more beautiful. Also lovely gift packaging as well, but the quality and craftmanship of the rings are beyond exquisite. Really am happy with my purchase. 2 out of 3 were supposed to be gifts I ended up keeping them all! All three are so pretty I often cannot decide which one to wear. Perfect for any occasion but especially holidays. Top shelf customer service from Italo Jewelry. Such class, courtesy and professionalism, very responsive, very helpful. Will definitely be ordering more from Italo! Wholeheartedly recommend to all.

Date of experience: December 27, 2023
Massachusetts
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Lynda M.
Unfollow Lynda M.
Share Review
Report Review

I ordered earrings for my daughter to wear on Christmas Eve on November 17. It is now December 20th and they have not been delivered. When I attempted to use Italo's website tracking function, it claims not to recognize their own tracking number - that they sent to me via email. You can't reach them by phone. The live chat operator just tells you they're in transit with no detail. According to the website delivery was to take place in 8-10 days. SCAM

Date of experience: December 20, 2023
New Jersey
3 reviews
2 helpful votes
Follow Nicole S.
Unfollow Nicole S.
Share Review
Report Review

I was looking at the site, put something in my cart to see discount, reviews & shipping costs. Before I finished the site submitted and charged me to pay-pal. I don't use PayPal and I was just looking. I have written 25 times, called 3 times and am being ignored. My bank is looking into fraud.

Date of experience: December 1, 2023
Florida
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Marketing C.
Unfollow Marketing C.
Share Review
Report Review

Horrible products. Purchased a bunch at the same. Started noticing green finger. Material of ring fading. Emailed CS. The reply we received was sorry over 1 year, buy a different one and here's a coupon code.

Actual deterioration because around month 6. And never wear them all day straight.

Terrible quality. Terrible cs.

Final thought. If you want a men's ring to last say 4-6 months, minimal wear - invest in this.

Date of experience: November 24, 2023
New York
1 review
4 helpful votes
Follow B B.
Unfollow B B.
Share Review
Report Review

Not trustworthy!
November 21, 2023

If you order anything then quickly change your mind, even earlier according to THEIR policy, or doesn't matter. Ordered something late at night and decided not to. Quickly emailed them to cancel. They respond weekdays very early in the morning EST. They didn't respond for over 24 hours later. Then told me they intercepted the shipment which was a total lie because my order shipped anyway. They didn't wait for me to answer back. I followed their policy and still got screwed. Then they took almost a month to refund.

DONT DO BUSINESS WITH THESE PEOPLE!

Date of experience: November 21, 2023
Arizona
5 reviews
10 helpful votes
Follow Dorothy D.
Unfollow Dorothy D.
Share Review
Report Review

Haven't received order I paid for. They keep sending emails saying they're going to express deliver. Doesn't happen. Over and over. They have my money. I have nothing!

Date of experience: October 25, 2023
Canada
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Barb E.
Unfollow Barb E.
Share Review
Report Review

Disappointment
October 10, 2023

The rings I received looked very nice, but I thought the stones were too big for my taste so I decided to return them and choose another style. I returned the rings at my own cost and tracked the packed so i knew it had been received. After two weeks of waiting (after the package I returned had been received) I asked when the replacement order was shipped. They had not yet shipped my order. I asked for a refund after waitng another period of time (after many emails) and finally threatened to dispute the transaction with Visa they finally gave me a refund but not the full amount. I will never order from here again no matter how beautiful their rings appear.

Date of experience: October 10, 2023

From the business

Choose your unique engagement/wedding rings online at Italojewelry.com. Fine quality engagement rings, wedding rings, bridal sets are available in various designs and colors. Enjoy Italo Jewelry online at best price.


italojewelry.com
COMMERCE, CALIFORNIA, United States
+117